Granny Mum family sign in

Home › Her life History

XIV. Politics, work and the argument

She was raised in a house where nobody argued except her:

“She got very upset when I argued with my father, which I did a lot… No, it was just me. I was arguing all the time.“

Her mother voted Conservative “but it didn’t have any thought behind it”. The politics went the other way a generation later. Ella, in old age, told her grandson — then about seven or eight, and repeating what he had picked up at home — “well, you’re only young, you’ll understand.” The phrase “the rampant socialism that was present in our household” is his, about the house Elizabeth and Tony kept, and it is not ironic: it was true, certainly of his father.

In the 1960s and after she was a member of CND — a member, not a worker or a volunteer — and a member and a volunteer of Shelter; homelessness and social justice generally were where her politics went. In the 1980s and 1990s she worked at Callmaster.

Her son puts to her, at length and rather searchingly, that she held progressive views while living in a social world that was not progressive about women. She agrees, and names the friends who were political. The exchange is the most self-examining passage in either recording, and it ends with her saying: “We’ve never had a conversation about this before.”

The friends, named:

the Warmans · the Seiberts · the Kohns · the Noons · the Greens · the Brodericks · the Earlams · Steve and Marge

and, from the recording, “Layla and Nigel, Michael Mary” — ✅ both closed, 4 September 2026 (Will): Leila and Nigel WATLING, and Michael and Mary WARMAN — who are the Warmans already on the list above, so the two entries are one household. Mary Warman is alive and telephones Elizabeth.

These are the social world she is describing, and the ones she calls political. Worth a page of their own at some point: family friends are the part of a life that no record holds and that disappears completely within one generation.


The establishment she was arguing with was in the family. There were Freemasons on her mother’s side, and she thinks both Ken and her grandfather were among them — the archive has since confirmed the grandfather: Captain Sutherland was initiated into the Minerva Lodge, Liverpool, in December 1920. Uncle Edwin took her to a Masonic ladies’ night as a teenager, “and I had to get dressed up for it.” Then four words: “And I hated it.” She notes, of the whole period, that “people didn’t talk about politics.”

It was the evening she hated, not Edwin: “No, he was a nice man, really. Quite sweet.” — “I didn’t like either the dressing up or the pomp of what’s supposed to be a special night.” Ken, her grandfather and Edwin were all Masons; it “didn’t impinge” and carried none of its present reputation — “mind you, I lived in a conservative household” — and “personality-wise I was quite like my mother; she didn’t like things like that.” (9 Sep 2026)

CND, Shelter and the CAB — what she actually did

  • CND: members, not activists. “I don’t think I was a volunteer… we were members.”
  • Shelter: a member AND a volunteer, and she names who brought her in — ★ Kate Seibert, of the Seiberts on the friends list, “beautiful, very clever, and such a good person”, who slept out in winter for it. Elizabeth did not: “I was probably just too busy. I wouldn’t have done that.”
  • The awakening tracks the Open University and the party years, and one man recurs: Steve James, “one of our good friends, and a Labour union representative”: the Steve of Steve and Marge on the friends list, a BOAC pilot who lived in Glen Road, and the neighbour through whom Tony joined the Labour Party in 1961 (Tony’s memoir, pp. 29–30).
  • She dates her own political formation to about 1977–78, alongside the degree — and she gave Will Nineteen Eighty-Four in 1984.

Private against state education was an active conversation throughout the marriage. Tony was on the side of state; she was, on occasion, in favour of private — the school considered for Suzanne, below, is one such occasion. Their friends’ children were generally state educated. This sits apart from the wider political stance, and she was not a radical anyway: it was a running argument about their own children, not a position.

⚠ And her own account of how much she knew

The second interview complicates this section considerably, and the complication should stand rather than be smoothed away.

Asked what the 1970s meant to her — the oil shock, the winter of discontent, Watergate, industrial strife — her answer is unqualified:

“Not at all. It just makes me think I didn’t know anything about anything.”

She remembers “the Bay of Pigs as a phrase, but I don’t know what it was”, and does not remember the Cuban missile crisis reaching her at all, though she knows Maureen was in California and found the supermarkets empty. She cried at Kennedy’s assassination.

Radio 4 is her instrument and always has been. “It’s still part of my life, even though I think it’s rubbish now — but it’s still my barometer on the world.” She traces it straight back to her parents: Charles making Ella two cups of tea and the Today programme on every morning, and to a house where “Radio 4 was on, because there wasn’t an alternative anyway.”

How this squares with CND and Shelter is a real question, not a contradiction to be tidied up. The likeliest reading is that her politics were moral and local — homelessness, the treatment of women, the way people are spoken to — and that she is telling the exact truth when she says she did not follow events. ❓ Put it to her directly. It is the most interesting unresolved thing about her.

On her children’s schooling she was the opposite of disengaged: “I was very, very into it. I’m bewildered by Caroline, who isn’t at all.”


The people who appear once in this session and are then gone — nineteen names from part 14 — are in Appendix C, where every such name now goes.

CUT: private education, recovered 8 Sep 2026 from a dropped stretch of tape — a private school in Camberley was considered for Suzanne, who had missed a lot of school through illness and needed to catch up; Elizabeth was keen, Tony was not — “he was very… a very determined person” — and “we had lots of hours of our own” over it; “I still think it might have been helpful.” Then a long passage against private education — “I don’t support private education… it is a passageway through to a kind of status in this country… that is what’s wrong deeply with the whole country” — ⚠ unlabelled, and by its cadence more likely Will’s than hers; Sue and Malcolm Robertson sent one child privately “because he was having difficulties”; and a memory that Stuart went somewhere for sixth form. She closes it herself: “nothing else really to say about it.” (6 Sep 2026, part of the recording, 3:12–7:57.)