Home › Ancestry › People in the tree History
Catharine Beauchamp
The account
Married Edward Sutherland, BEF 1839. Children: William John Edward Graham Sutherland (b. 7 FEB 1839).
Recorded events
- Living at 1851, Middlesex, England
Sources cited
- Ancestry census search-result index rows (1851 and 1871 England Census)
- Ancestry.com
What the evidence says
catharine-hales-candidate — unverified
Major Edward Sutherland’s first wife may have been CATHARINE ANN HALES, a widow, whom an Edward Sutherland married on 4 March 1821 at Newport, Hampshire.
“Catharine Ann Hales, Female, Marital Status: Widowed, Marriage Date: 4 Mar 1821, Marriage Place: Newport, Hampshire, England, Spouse: Edward Sutherland”
Source: Ancestry ‘shoebox’ printouts, saved and printed August 2023
Reasoning. IT FITS THE LETTER ALMOST TOO NEATLY, WHICH IS ITSELF A REASON FOR CAUTION. Nellie Sutherland’s 1938 letter says the Major’s first wife was a WIDOW; this bride is expressly recorded as widowed, and her forename matches the ‘Catharine’ from the 1851 census index. Newport, Isle of Wight, was the garrison town of Albany Barracks. An 1821 marriage leaves eighteen years before the 1839 birth of the only son, which is the shape Nellie describes - ‘a heap of daughters and one son’. AGAINST IT: Major Edward Sutherland was born c.1799-1801, making him only 20 or 21 in March 1821, young to marry a widow; Edward Sutherland is a common name; and this is an index entry, not the register. IT ALSO CUTS ACROSS WILL’S OWN TESTIMONY of 27 Jul 2026 that Catharine’s surname was BEAUCHAMP. Both are recorded and they cannot both be right. The likeliest reconciliation is that Beauchamp/Beauchant is a genuine family name remembered one generation displaced - Eliza Cregoe BEAUCHANT married this woman’s SON - in which case Hales is her first husband’s name and her maiden name is still unknown.
Next. View or order the Newport, Isle of Wight parish register entry for 4 Mar 1821. It should give his age, rank and regiment and her father’s name, and would settle in one document both whether this is our man and whether Beauchamp belongs to her.
Notes and reasoning
3 notes, in the order written. Later notes may correct earlier ones; both are kept deliberately.
[0] Almost certainly Will’s 4x great-grandmother - the first wife of Major Edward Sutherland and mother of William John Edward Graham Sutherland. EVIDENCE IS THIN AND MUST BE HELD LIGHTLY: her forename comes from a single Ancestry SEARCH-RESULT ROW for the 1851 England Census, which lists Edward Sutherland (b. abt 1801, Middlesex) with spouse “Catharine”. The record detail page is behind Ancestry’s paywall and has NOT been read. The surname Sutherland here is her married name; her maiden name is unknown, and per Nellie Sutherland’s 1938 letter she was a WIDOW when Edward married her, so she may appear in earlier records under a first husband’s surname. Sequence: with Edward in 1851; by the 1871 census his wife is “Mary B” (Mary Bradford Johns), so Catharine died between 1851 and 1871 - which fits Nellie’s description of Edward as “a widower with a heap of daughters and one son” when he remarried. Those daughters are still entirely unrecorded.
[1] SURNAME SUPPLIED BY WILL, 27 Jul 2026: BEAUCHAMP. Recorded as Will’s testimony, not as a document - the source and its strength have been queried and are not yet answered, so this is held as UNVERIFIED pending that answer. IT REVERSES A CONCLUSION IN THIS FILE. The 1938 letter of Nellie Sutherland contains the word “Beauchant”, flagged with the modern transcriber’s own “(?)” uncertainty mark, in a passage about a cousin’s claim of “Beauchant superiority in point of birth”. The first reading here attached that name to Major Edward Sutherland’s FIRST WIFE; on 26 Jul that reading was talked down in favour of the name entering by one of the Major’s daughters MARRYING a Beauchant. Will’s confirmation says the first reading was right. Both the earlier reasoning and this correction are kept - see the beauchant-dispute claim in. TWO CONSEQUENCES. (1) “Beauchant” in the transcript is very probably BEAUCHAMP misread, which removes the doubtful word and means the letter and Will are naming the same family. (2) OPEN QUESTION, NOT YET RESOLVED: Nellie states the first marriage was to A WIDOW, so Beauchamp may be Catharine’s MAIDEN name or her FIRST HUSBAND’S. “Superiority in point of birth” is an argument about descent, which favours maiden - and this record has been written that way, with Sutherland kept as a married-name alias. If Beauchamp proves to be a first married name, her maiden name is still unknown and a first husband named Beauchamp must be found. THE SEARCHES THIS OPENS: a Sutherland-Beauchamp marriage c.1830-1838 (their son was born Feb 1839 in Ayrshire), in the GRO index from Jul 1837 or a parish register before it; and the Beauchant/Beauchamp family of FALMOUTH, Cornwall - Theophilus Samuel Beauchant (1787-1849), Royal Marine Artillery, Cornwall Militia, First Magistrate of Falmouth - for a daughter Catharine b. c.1800-1815.
[2] DIRECTLY CONTRADICTED FIVE DAYS LATER, 2 Aug 2026, AND THE CONTRADICTION IS WILL’S OWN ARCHIVE. Among the Ancestry printouts saved in Aug 2023 and photographed into this archive is an entry from “England, Select Marriages, 1538-1973”: CATHARINE ANN HALES, female, marital status WIDOWED, married 4 Mar 1821 at NEWPORT, HAMPSHIRE, spouse EDWARD SUTHERLAND (FHL film 1470881). See. IF THAT IS OUR COUPLE IT FITS REMARKABLY WELL. Nellie Sutherland’s 1938 letter says the Major’s first wife was a WIDOW - and this bride is expressly recorded as widowed. Newport, Isle of Wight, was the garrison town of Albany Barracks, exactly where a young soldier would be found. Marrying in 1821 leaves eighteen years before the 1839 birth of the only son, which is precisely the shape Nellie describes: “a heap of daughters and one son”. On that reading her first husband was named HALES, and her maiden name is still unknown. WHAT IT DOES TO “BEAUCHAMP”. The Beauchamp/Beauchant name now has a documented route into this family that has nothing to do with Catharine: ELIZA CREGOE BEAUCHANT married this woman’s son, W.J.E.G. Sutherland, in Sept 1878 - see. That is very probably what Will was remembering, one generation and one marriage displaced. NEITHER CLAIM IS BEING DELETED. The Will’s testimony stands recorded above; this record stands beside it; both are unverified and they cannot both be right. THE TEST IS CHEAP: Major Edward Sutherland was born c.1799-1801, so he was twenty or twenty-one in Mar 1821 - young, though not impossibly so, for a soldier marrying a widow. Order or view the Newport parish register entry for 4 Mar 1821; it will give his age, his rank and regiment, and her father’s name, and will settle in one document whether this is our man and whether Beauchamp belongs to her at all.