Granny Mum family sign in

Home › Ancestry › People in the tree History

Edward Sutherland

BET 1799 AND 1801 – 24 Aug 1884

The account

Born BET 1799 AND 1801 at Halifax, Nova Scotia, British North America. Occupation: Retired Major of the Army. Married Mary Bradford Johns, BET 1851 AND 1871, at England. Married Catharine Beauchamp, BEF 1839. Children: William John Edward Graham Sutherland (b. 7 FEB 1839). Died 24 Aug 1884 at 2 Osbourne Place, Plymouth, Devon, England.

Recorded events

  • Born BET 1799 AND 1801, Halifax, Nova Scotia, British North America
  • Living at 1851, Chelsea, Middlesex, England CHELSEA, not just “Middlesex” - the fuller place only appeared when the search was re-run with “Chelsea” as a keyword, 26 Jul 2026. It matters because the Royal Hospital Chelsea administered army pensions, and Ancestry holds several Edward Sutherland entries in its pension and admission registers, one of them recording a death in 1884.
  • Living at 1871, London, England
  • Living at 1881, 10 Pembroke Gardens, Kensington, London, England
  • Died 24 Aug 1884, 2 Osbourne Place, Plymouth, Devon, England DOES DEVON CONFLICT WITH THE LONDON CAREER? No. He was at Kensington in 1881 and a Gentleman- at-Arms in London in 1870, and died at Plymouth in 1884 - but three years is ample to move, he was 84, and PLYMOUTH WAS THE OBVIOUS PLACE for a retired officer to end up: a garrison and naval town with a large half-pay population, and cheaper than Kensington. The family kept the connection - his granddaughter Nellie was writing from Exmouth, Devon in 1938. The two records also corroborate each other rather than clashing: the address and date came originally from the unsourced Ancestry tree, and the GRO index independently registers a death at PLYMOUTH in the September quarter of 1884, aged 84. WHAT IT OPENS UP: the death certificate (about GBP 12.50 from the GRO on this index reference) gives the exact address, his occupation as stated at death, the cause, and crucially THE INFORMANT - normally a relative present at the death. That informant could be one of the “heap of daughters” from his first marriage whom we have never been able to name. The 1884 probate entry would add the executors and the estate.
  • Retired Major of the Army
  • Storekeeper, Royal Hospital Chelsea — 1850-1856, Royal Hospital, Chelsea, Middlesex, England THIS OVERTURNS THE CHELSEA PENSIONER STORY, and improves it. He was not a pensioner of the Royal Hospital - he was ON ITS STAFF, listed among the Governor, Chaplain, Physician, Surgeon, Chief Clerk and Captains of Invalids as STOREKEEPER, holding the rank of Captain on half-pay, Unattached. That is why the 1851 census puts him and Catharine at CHELSEA, Middlesex, and why his name turns up in Royal Hospital Chelsea record series. Elizabeth had the right institution and the wrong side of the counter.

Sources cited

  • [primary] 1881 England Census
  • The National Archives of the UK (TNA)
    • Class RG11; Piece 24; Folio 57; Page 27 - “Where born: Halifax, North America”
    • Class RG11; Piece 24; Folio 57; Page 27
  • Ancestry census search-result index rows (1851 and 1871 England Census)
  • Ancestry.com
    • 1871 England Census index row - Edward Sutherland b. 1801, spouse “Mary B”
    • 1851 England Census index row - Edward Sutherland b. abt 1801, spouse “Catharine”,
    • residence Chelsea
  • England & Wales, Civil Registration Death Index, 1837-1915
  • General Register Office
    • Jul-Aug-Sep 1884, Plymouth, Devonshire; vol 5b p.181
  • Letter from Nellie Sutherland to her brother Edward, 2 November 1938
  • Nellie Sutherland
  • The Army List (monthly and annual series), 1843-1883
  • War Office; H. G. Hart
    • New Annual Army List 1855, Military Establishments: “ROYAL HOSPITAL, CHELSEA …
    • Storekeeper, Captain Edward Sutherland, h. p. Unatt.”

What the evidence says

grandfather-first-marriage — plausible

Major Edward Sutherland’s first marriage was to a widow, and produced several daughters and one son (William John Edward Graham Sutherland). A certificate of that marriage survived in the family papers in 1938.

“a certificate of our grandfather’s first marriage, to a widow”

Source: Letter from Nellie Sutherland to her brother Edward, 2 November 1938

Reasoning. The one son matches the tree. The ‘heap of daughters’ are entirely absent from our record, so this opens a whole unrecorded sibling group. That the first wife was herself a widow means she may appear under a former married surname rather than her maiden one - worth knowing before searching.

Next. Find the first marriage c.1830s. Then census the household to recover the daughters.

royal-godfather — plausible

Major Edward Sutherland’s godfather was Queen Victoria’s father - Prince Edward Augustus, Duke of Kent and Strathearn (1767-1820) - and a document bearing the Duke’s signature was among the family papers in 1938, passing to ‘Irene’.

“also the signature of Queen Victoria’s father, who was our grandfather’s godfather”

Source: Letter from Nellie Sutherland to her brother Edward, 2 November 1938

Reasoning. The identification is certain: Queen Victoria’s father was Prince Edward, Duke of Kent and Strathearn. UPGRADED 26 Jul 2026 by the Army Lists, read free as OCR text from the Internet Archive. (1) HE SERVED IN THE 7th FOOT. The 1870 New Annual Army List lists him among the Gentlemen-at-Arms as ‘Major Edward Sutherland, LATE OF 7 F’. The 7th Foot is the ROYAL FUSILIERS - the regiment the Duke of Kent was Colonel of from 1789, and the regiment that went to Canada in 1791. That regiment was identified as the sharpest target for this claim BEFORE the Army List was searched, on the reasoning that a godfathership would most likely arise through the Duke’s own corps. Finding him actually in it is the strongest circumstantial support this claim has. (2) HE WAS COMMISSIONED, settling the doubt raised by the Chelsea connection: the Army List names commissioned officers only. His Chelsea link was as STOREKEEPER on the Royal Hospital’s staff, not as a pensioner. (3) The Halifax birth is already record-confirmed by the 1881 census, and the death index puts the birth at 1799-1801 - inside the Duke’s second Halifax posting (Sept 1799 - Aug 1800). (4) STILL MISSING: no record of the godfathership itself. Everything above is the frame. And note the circle rather than mistaking it for proof - the family says the Duke stood godfather to him, and he ended his career in personal attendance on the Duke’s daughter as one of the Sovereign’s Gentlemen-at-Arms. IDENTITY CAVEAT: the Army List entries are matched on name, rank, period and place, not on a birth date. More than one Major Edward Sutherland could exist.

Next. PRIORITY 1: WO 76 officers’ services for the 7th Foot - now that the regiment is known, this is a targeted search rather than a fishing trip, and it gives birthplace and often parentage. PRIORITY 2: Hart’s Army List gives commission DATES and war services; work back from 1870 to find his first commission and his father’s details if printed. PRIORITY 3: the Halifax baptism enquiry to St Paul’s, drafted and in Gmail drafts - now able to say he later served in the Duke’s own regiment. PRIORITY 4: trace ‘Irene’ and the signed paper.

Documents

  • named in Letter from Nellie Sutherland to her brother Edward, 2 November 1938 — grandfather of the writer and recipient

Notes and reasoning

1 note, in the order written. Later notes may correct earlier ones; both are kept deliberately.

[0] RECORD-CONFIRMED 26 Jul 2026 from the 1881 census and the GRO death index. 1881 census (RG11/24/57 p.27): “Edward Sutherland, 80, Head, Married, Retired Major of the Army, where born HALIFAX, NORTH AMERICA”, living at 10 Pembroke Gardens, Kensington, with wife Mary B. Sutherland, 77, a visitor Frances Power 51, and two servants. GRO death index: died Jul-Aug-Sep 1884, Plymouth, Devonshire, AGE 84, vol 5b p.181. The two together put his birth in roughly 1799-1801. This supersedes an earlier assessment that the Halifax birthplace was an uncited Ancestry-tree assertion - it is now independent record evidence, and it also confirms the rank and the marriage to Mary Bradford Johns, both of which had rested on Nellie Sutherland’s 1938 letter alone. THE ROYAL CLAIM: the letter says Prince Edward, Duke of Kent, father of Queen Victoria, was his GODFATHER, and that a paper bearing the Duke’s signature was in the family in 1938, passing to “Irene”. The Duke commanded at Halifax 1794-Oct 1798 and again Sept 1799-Aug 1800. A birth in 1799-1800 falls INSIDE that second posting, so the earlier objection - that the Duke had gone before the child was born - is substantially weakened. The godfathership itself still rests only on the letter. Married twice: first to a widow, name unknown (F11), one son and several daughters; second to the widowed Mary Bradford Johns (F33), no children. Parents still unknown.