Home › Ancestry › Ella Mary Edith Wynne, née Sutherland History
Ella Mary Edith Sutherland (from the family tree)
abt 1905 – ?
The account
Born abt 1905 at Liverpool, Lancashire, England. Child of Edward William Rose Jasper Sutherland and Annie Sheen. Married Charles Wynne, Apr 1933, at Liverpool, Lancashire, United Kingdom. Children: Elizabeth Hancock (b. 2 Sep 1936).
Siblings recorded: Rollo Sutherland
Recorded events
- Born abt 1905, Liverpool, Lancashire, England
- Living at 1911, Wavertree, England
Sources cited
- 1911 England Census
- Ancestry.com
- The National Archives of the UK (TNA); Kew, Surrey, England; Census Returns of England and
- Wales, 1911
- Ancestry Family Trees
- Ancestry Family Tree
- England & Wales, Civil Registration Marriage Index, 1916-2005
- Ancestry.com
- Liverpool, England, Church of England Marriages and Banns, 1754-1935
- Ancestry.com
- Liverpool Record Office; Liverpool, England; Reference Number: 283 AHA/3/2
What the evidence says
ella-baptism-anomaly — plausible
Ella Mary Edith Sutherland was baptised 18 August 1904 at Toxteth St Thomas, daughter of Edward William Sutherland and Annie; the birth date shown alongside is wrong.
“Baptism Date: 18 Aug 1904, Baptism Place: Toxteth, St Thomas, Lancashire, England; Father: Edward William Sutherland; Mother: Annie Sutherland”
Source: Ancestry ‘shoebox’ printouts, saved and printed August 2023
Reasoning. The printout carries a birth date of 20 Nov 1888 against this baptism, which is Zoe Stephanie Catherine Sutherland’s birth date from a different entry on the same page - an index or transcription bleed, not a real date. The 1911 census independently gives Ella as aged 6, born about 1905, which is consistent with an Aug 1904 baptism and with the birth ‘abt 1905’ already carried in this tree. A worked example of why this whole document is graded derivative.
Next. The Toxteth St Thomas register entry itself, or a GRO birth certificate, will give her actual birth date.
ella-wynne-marriage-date — plausible
Ella Mary Edith Sutherland married Charles Wynne on or about Monday 12 June 1933, not in April 1933.
“I am looking forward to the duty which devolves on me on Monday”
Source: Letter of 8 June 1933 from ‘Nancy’ and Otho to their niece Ella Sutherland, on the eve of her marriage
Reasoning. The letter is dated Thursday 8 June 1933 and anticipates giving the bride away ‘on Monday’ - the Monday following is 12 June 1933. The tree’s existing ‘Apr 1933’ comes from a GRO index reference, and GRO indexes are QUARTERLY: the April-May-June quarter is routinely rendered as ‘Apr’. A June wedding registers in that quarter, so the letter and the index agree rather than conflict, and the letter is the more precise of the two. Short of the certificate this is the best date available.
Next. Order the GRO marriage certificate for Wynne x Sutherland, Liverpool, June quarter 1933 (the tree already cites vol 8b p 14). It gives the exact day, both fathers’ names and occupations, the church and the witnesses - and the witnesses may identify ‘Nancy’ and Otho.
uncle-gave-ella-away — plausible
An uncle, not her father, gave Ella away at her 1933 wedding.
“the duty which devolves on me on Monday … one does not like to give away”
Source: Letter of 8 June 1933 from ‘Nancy’ and Otho to their niece Ella Sutherland, on the eve of her marriage
Reasoning. The writer addresses her as ‘My dear Niece’ and describes the duty of giving away as devolving on him. Her father Edward William Rose Jasper Sutherland did not die until 11 Apr 1942, so he was alive and aged about 62. An uncle standing in when the father is living is not remarkable on its own - illness, absence at sea, or simple preference would explain it, and he was a master mariner who may well have been away - but it is the kind of small anomaly worth carrying, because it may connect to something later.
Next. The marriage certificate names the witnesses. Identify ‘Nancy’ and Otho - Otho is an uncommon forename and should be findable in Liverpool records, and 298 Utting Avenue East, West Derby is a specific address to search in the 1939 Register.
Documents
- Letter of 8 June 1933 from ‘Nancy’ and Otho to their niece Ella Sutherland, on the eve of her marriage (recipient) — 1933-06-08
- named in Letter from Nellie Sutherland to her brother Edward, 2 November 1938 — thanked for trouble taken over the funeral
Transcript — Letter of 8 June 1933 from ‘Nancy’ and Otho to their niece Ella Sutherland, on the eve of her marriage
``` 298 Utting Avenue East West Derby. Liverpool 11.
June 8th /33.
My dear Niece, Ella,
These few lines - on behalf of all the "Wicks" [reading uncertain] - to wish you & Charlie a full measure of Happiness & Prosperity throughout your married life.
I am looking forward to the duty which devolves on me on Monday, I [attend?] with mixed feelings: naturally, that one likes - one does not like to give away, and I'd sooner it has to be done, and I'll endeavour to do my part in a satisfactory manner.
Please accept the enclosure with our united love, and - - - - God Bless you!
Your affectionate "Nancy"
& Otho
```