Home › Ancestry › People in the tree History
James Nicholls
18 OCT 1831 – ABT 1917
The account
Born 18 OCT 1831 at Gustaveor, St Columb Minor, Cornwall, England. Occupation: Physician and surgeon; M.D., L.R.C.P., L.M.. Child of John Nicholls and Amelia Ann Johns. Died ABT 1917.
Siblings recorded: Mary Nicholls
Recorded events
- Born 18 OCT 1831, Gustaveor, St Columb Minor, Cornwall, England Born on ST LUKE’S DAY, which the obituary remarks on - Luke being the physician among the evangelists, and this man became a doctor. He was born ten months after his parents’ marriage of 4 Dec 1830, which fits the obituary calling him the ELDEST SON.
- Died ABT 1917 DERIVED from the obituary’s statement that he died aged 85, against a birth of Oct 1831 - so 1916 or 1917. The cutting itself is undated.
- Physician and surgeon; M.D., L.R.C.P., L.M.
Sources cited
- Newspaper cutting - obituary, “LATE DR. JAMES NICHOLLS”
- Unattributed; a Cornish newspaper, probably the Royal Cornwall Gazette or West Briton
- “The death is announced, at the age of 85…”
- ”…at Gustaveor, in St. Columb Minor, Oct. 18, 1831”
What the evidence says
james-nicholls-identity — corroborated
Dr James Nicholls, born 18 October 1831 at Gustaveor, St Columb Minor, and died aged 85, was the eldest son of John Nicholls and Amelia Ann Johns, and therefore the elder brother of Mary Nicholls.
“eldest son of the late John Nicholls, of Trekenning House, St. Columb”
Source: Newspaper cutting - obituary, ‘LATE DR. JAMES NICHOLLS’
Reasoning. John Nicholls married Amelia Ann Johns on 4 December 1830; a birth ten months later, in Oct 1831, is exactly right for an eldest child, and the obituary independently calls him the eldest son. The birthplace matches the parish where the rest of this household is recorded.
Next. His baptism at St Columb Minor c.1831 should name both parents and confirm the join outright. His own marriage, children and probate are all findable and he practised in West Somerset.
nicholls-martyn-kinship — plausible
Dr Edward Martyn, to whom James Nicholls was apprenticed in London, was a RELATIVE of the Nicholls family.
“went as ‘apprentice’ (the proper approach [to the] medical profession) to a relative, Dr. Edward Martyn”
Source: Newspaper cutting - obituary, ‘LATE DR. JAMES NICHOLLS’
Reasoning. INDEPENDENT SUPPORT FOR THE OLDEST PART OF THE HAND-DRAWN SHEET. The maternal sheet traces this family back through Margaret Martyn who married Richard Johns, and beyond her to Thomas Martyn, yeoman of Crantock, married 1696 - all of it uncorroborated family compilation. Here a printed obituary, written for a general readership and with no interest in genealogy, calls a Dr Edward Martyn ‘a relative’. Two sources of quite different kinds agreeing on a Nicholls/Johns-Martyn kinship is worth considerably more than either alone. It stops short of corroborated because the obituary does not say HOW he was related.
Next. Identify Dr Edward Martyn in the London medical registers and directories of the 1840s-50s, then work back to his parentage; if he descends from the Crantock Martyns the hand-drawn sheet gains real credit.
Notes and reasoning
1 note, in the order written. Later notes may correct earlier ones; both are kept deliberately.
[0] MARY NICHOLLS’ ELDEST BROTHER, and Will’s 3x great-uncle. His obituary is the most informative cutting in the archive, because of where it puts the family. HIS CAREER as the cutting gives it: a former pupil of Dr Dimock at the Grammar School, Truro; apprenticed in the usual way to a relative, DR EDWARD MARTYN, in London; entered St George’s Hospital as a student; qualified at Apothecaries’ Hall at 21; took his M.D. at St Andrews, and his L.M. and L.R.C.P. London in 1867; practised many years in West Somerset. THE MARTYN APPRENTICESHIP IS EVIDENCE, NOT COLOUR: the hand-drawn maternal sheet at traces this family to Thomas MARTYN of Crantock, and here is an independent printed source calling a Dr Edward Martyn “a relative”. Two sources of different kinds agreeing on a Nicholls-Martyn kinship is worth more than either alone. Legibility is poor at the available resolution and parts of this reading are uncertain, the qualification dates especially.