Granny Mum family sign in

Home › Ancestry › People in the tree History

Mary Bradford Johns

25 DEC 1800 – AFT 3 APR 1881

The account

Born 25 DEC 1800. Child of John Johns and Elizabeth Bradford. Married Edward Sutherland, BET 1851 AND 1871, at England. Married Colonel Saunders, BEF 1851, at India (believed). Died AFT 3 APR 1881.

Siblings recorded: Amelia Ann Johns

Recorded events

  • Born 25 DEC 1800
  • Living at 1871, London, England
  • Living at 1881, 10 Pembroke Gardens, Kensington, London, England
  • Died AFT 3 APR 1881 No death record found. She was alive and aged 77 at the 1881 census, so she died after it; that is the only firm bound we have.

Sources cited

  • [primary] 1881 England Census
  • The National Archives of the UK (TNA)
    • Class RG11; Piece 24; Folio 57; Page 27
    • Class RG11; Piece 24; Folio 57; Page 27 - “Mary B. Sutherland, 77, Wife”
  • Ancestry census search-result index rows (1851 and 1871 England Census)
  • Ancestry.com
    • 1871 England Census index row - Edward Sutherland, spouse “Mary B”
  • Letter from Nellie Sutherland to her brother Edward, 2 November 1938
  • Nellie Sutherland

What the evidence says

great-aunt-identity — corroborated

Mary Bradford Johns, born 25 December 1800, was the sister of ‘Grandma Nicholls’ (Amelia Ann Johns, who married John Nicholls in 1830) and therefore a daughter of John Johns and Elizabeth Bradford.

“it is a watercolour (lady in gray dress) and is of Grandma Nicholls’ sister (our great aunt), born December 25th 1800. Mary Bradford Johns”

Source: Letter from Nellie Sutherland to her brother Edward, 2 November 1938

Reasoning. Her middle name IS her mother’s maiden name. The hand-drawn maternal sheet independently gives John Johns’s wife as Elizabeth Bradford, a claim that until now was sheet-sourced only and unconfirmed. A daughter christened Mary BRADFORD Johns is exactly the naming pattern that would follow, and the letter’s author had no sight of the sheet. Two independent sources converging on Bradford is strong. The 1800 birth also sits correctly against Amelia’s 1808 baptism at Crantock.

Next. Find a Mary Bradford Johns baptism c.1800-01 in Cornwall (Crantock, St Columb, or nearby) naming John and Elizabeth.

great-aunt-second-marriage — corroborated

As a widow, and against her family’s wishes, Mary Bradford Johns married Major Edward Sutherland (b. 1801 Halifax, Nova Scotia) as his second wife. She had no children by either husband.

“she returned to England, and against the wishes of her family, married our grandfather, Major Edward Sutherland, then a widower with a heap of daughters and one son, our father. She was much respected by all her step-children (no children by either husband)”

Source: Letter from Nellie Sutherland to her brother Edward, 2 November 1938

Reasoning. CORROBORATED 26 Jul 2026 by the 1881 census (RG11/24/57 p.27): Edward Sutherland, 80, Retired Major of the Army, living at 10 Pembroke Gardens, Kensington with his wife ‘Mary B. Sutherland’, aged 77. The initial and the marriage are exactly as Nellie describes; this is no longer letter- only. Their childlessness is consistent with the household, which contains no children. One discrepancy to note honestly: age 77 in April 1881 implies a birth about 1803-04, whereas Nellie gives 25 Dec 1800. Census ages are frequently a few years out, and the letter’s precise date is the sort of detail a family remembers, but the two do not agree exactly. The first marriage, to a widow, and the ‘heap of daughters’ remain unevidenced.

Next. Find the Sutherland-Saunders marriage in the GRO index (post-1837) to fix her maiden name, her father and her true birth year. Also check the 1871 and 1851 censuses, where the couple should appear together.

mary-bradford-two-marriages-corroborated — corroborated

Mary Bradford Johns, born 1800, married first a Saunders with the initial J., and second Edward Sutherland.

“Mary B. 1800 - m. 1st J. Saunders - 2nd Edward Sutherland”

Source: Hand-drawn maternal family tree - the UNCROPPED photograph, recovering the top line and left column

Reasoning. TWO INDEPENDENT SOURCES NOW AGREE ON THE SEQUENCE. Nellie Sutherland’s letter of 2 Nov 1938 says the great-aunt ‘married Colonel Saunders, went to India with him… he died, I believe out there: she returned to England, and against the wishes of her family, married our grandfather, Major Edward Sutherland’. This sheet, in another hand and with no sight of the letter, gives the same two marriages in the same order with the same birth year. The sheet adds an INITIAL for Saunders - J. - which the letter does not supply, and which narrows a search of the India Office records considerably.

Next. Search the British Library India Office Records N-series for a marriage or burial of a Colonel J. Saunders, and for a Mary Saunders returning to England; and the GRO index after 1837 for the Sutherland marriage.

double-connection — plausible

The Johns and Sutherland families are joined twice, a generation apart: Mary Bradford Johns married into the Sutherlands as Major Edward Sutherland’s second wife, and a generation later her great-niece Mary Nicholls (granddaughter of Mary’s sister Amelia) married that same Major’s son. Mary Bradford Johns was thus blood kin on the mother’s side and step-kin on the father’s, which is precisely the point Nellie is at pains to explain.

“you see, she was no blood relative of second family”

Source: Letter from Nellie Sutherland to her brother Edward, 2 November 1938

Reasoning. Follows arithmetically from the two marriage claims plus the recorded 1867 marriage of William John Edward Graham Sutherland to Mary Nicholls. It is also the only reading on which Nellie’s closing sentence makes sense, which is good internal evidence that she has the relationships right.

Next. Confirm the second marriage and the great-aunt’s parentage; the rest is arithmetic.

great-aunt-first-marriage — unverified

Mary Bradford Johns married first a Colonel Saunders of the Indian Army, went out to India with him, and was widowed there.

“she married Colonel Saunders, went to India with him (he was Indian army), he died, I believe out there”

Source: Letter from Nellie Sutherland to her brother Edward, 2 November 1938

Reasoning. Nellie flags her own doubt about the place of death (‘I believe out there’), which is a mark of a careful witness rather than a fabricator. No independent evidence yet. ‘Indian army’ in this period means the East India Company armies or, after 1858, the Indian Army proper; for a marriage c.1820-40 the former is likely.

Next. Search British Library India Office Records (N series ecclesiastical returns) for a Saunders marriage or burial, and for a Mary Saunders returning to England.

Objects

  • Watercolour portrait, ‘lady in gray dress’ — held In Will’s living room, hanging on a boarded wall; photographed in situ 1 Aug 2026.
  • Miniature portrait of the great-aunt — unlocated

Notes and reasoning

1 note, in the order written. Later notes may correct earlier ones; both are kept deliberately.

[0] RECORD-CONFIRMED as Edward Sutherland’s wife by the 1881 census (RG11/24/57 p.27), which lists “Mary B. Sutherland, 77, Wife” in his household at 10 Pembroke Gardens, Kensington - the initial and the marriage exactly as Nellie describes, and no longer letter-only. NOTE A DISCREPANCY: age 77 in April 1881 implies a birth about 1803-04, whereas Nellie gives 25 December 1800. Census ages are often a few years out and a precise date is the sort of thing a family remembers, but the two do not agree. Will’s 4x great-aunt on the maternal line, and separately his 3x great- step-grandmother - the Johns and Sutherland families joined twice, a generation apart. Sister of Amelia Ann Johns (“Grandma Nicholls”), so a daughter of John Johns and Elizabeth Bradford; her middle name is her mother’s maiden name, which independently corroborates the hand-drawn sheet’s previously unconfirmed “John m. Elizabeth Bradford”. Married first Colonel Saunders of the Indian Army and went to India with him; widowed, believed in India. Returned to England and, against her family’s wishes, married Major Edward Sutherland as his second wife. No children by either marriage. Brought Indian rosewood furniture back from India. Subject of a large watercolour (lady in a gray dress) and of a miniature. Known only from the 2 Nov 1938 letter of Nellie Sutherland; no record evidence yet.