Home › Ancestry › People in the tree History
Mary Nicholls
abt 1843 – 5 May 1875
The account
Born abt 1843 at St Columb Minor, Cornwall, England. Child of John Nicholls and Amelia Ann Johns. Married William John Edward Graham Sutherland, 13 Nov 1867, at St Columb Major. Children: Nellie Sutherland, Edward William Rose Jasper Sutherland (b. January 1871). Died 5 May 1875.
Siblings recorded: James Nicholls
Recorded events
- Born abt 1843, St Columb Minor, Cornwall, England
- Baptised 21 Nov 1843, St Columb Minor,Cornwall,England
- Living at 1861, St Columb Major, Cornwall, England
- Died 5 May 1875
- Married October 1867, St Columb, Cornwall, United Kingdom
Sources cited
- 1861 England Census
- Ancestry.com
- Class: RG 9; Piece: 1542; Folio: 79; Page: 19; GSU roll: 542828
- Ancestry Family Trees
- Ancestry Family Tree
- England & Wales, Civil Registration Marriage Index, 1837-1915
- FreeBMD
- England, Select Births and Christenings, 1538-1975
- Ancestry.com
What the evidence says
sheet-mary-johns-married-sutherland — plausible
The sheet’s “Mary Johns ✕ W. Sutherland” is the same person the records name MARY NICHOLLS - daughter of John Nicholls and Amelia Ann Johns - who married William John Edward Graham Sutherland.
“Mary Johns ✕ W. Sutherland → son Edward Sutherland ✕ Miss A. Sheen → daughter Ella Sutherland ✕ Charles Wynne”
Source: Hand-drawn family tree — “rough copy of the … family — Mother’s [side]” (Johns / Sutherland / Wynne)
Reasoning. The sheet’s chain is identical to the recorded one: Mary → son Edward Sutherland who married an A. Sheen → daughter Ella who married Charles Wynne. In the records that is Mary Nicholls → Edward William Rose Jasper Sutherland (m. Annie Sheen 1897) → Ella Mary Edith Sutherland (m. Charles Wynne 1933). Three generations matching on names, spouses and sexes is not coincidence. The likeliest explanation for the surname is that this is a JOHNS tree and she is a Johns descendant through her mother Amelia Ann Johns, so the compiler wrote her under the trunk surname. The record side is well evidenced - 1843 baptism, 1861 census, GRO marriage index, 1867 marriage at St Columb Major. THIS MATTERS BECAUSE it is almost certainly the origin of the Will’s memory that a “Mary Johns” is his direct ancestor. He is right about the person and the sheet is wrong about her surname.
Next. The baptism of William John Edward Graham Sutherland (b. 7 Feb 1839, reportedly Ayrshire) names his mother and would settle it outright. Failing that, the 1871 census household at St Columb Major.
Documents
- named in Hand-drawn family tree — “rough copy of the … family — Mother’s [side]” (Johns / Sutherland / Wynne) — married W. Sutherland; head of the confident line