Granny Mum family sign in

Home › Ancestry › People in the tree History

Nellie Sutherland

The account

Child of William John Edward Graham Sutherland and Mary Nicholls.

Siblings recorded: Edward William Rose Jasper Sutherland

Recorded events

  • Living at 2 NOV 1938, 22 Waverley Road, Exmouth, Devon, England

Sources cited

  • Letter from Nellie Sutherland to her brother Edward, 2 November 1938
  • Nellie Sutherland

What the evidence says

nellie-is-sister — plausible

Nellie Sutherland was a sister of Edward William Rose Jasper Sutherland (b. Jan 1871), and so a daughter of William John Edward Graham Sutherland and Mary Nicholls.

“Your affectionate sister / Nellie”

Source: Letter from Nellie Sutherland to her brother Edward, 2 November 1938

Reasoning. She signs as his sister and speaks throughout of ‘our grandfather’, ‘our father’, ‘our great aunt’, ‘our mother’. One oddity cuts against a full sister: she opens ‘You seem to know so very little about YOUR mother’s relatives’, where a full sister would more naturally write ‘our’. She does write ‘our mother’s’ later in the same letter, so the likeliest reading is rhetorical emphasis rather than a half-relationship - but a half-sister or step-sister is not excluded.

Next. Census 1881/1891 for the household of William John Edward Graham Sutherland to list the children and settle it.

Documents

  • Letter from Nellie Sutherland to her brother Edward, 2 November 1938 (author) — 2 NOV 1938
  • named in Letter from Nellie Sutherland to her brother Edward, 2 November 1938 — writer; sister of Edward

Transcript — Letter from Nellie Sutherland to her brother Edward, 2 November 1938

``` Transcript of letter from Nellie Sutherland dated November 2nd 1938

22 Waverley Road Exmouth

Dear Edward

Thank you for your letter of this morning – I am so glad you were there to pay your last respect – weather fine, clergyman reverent, followers nice and all as far as possible, was seemly – she would have wished it quiet and simple.

You seem to know so very little about your mother’s relatives. I want to explain to you, how carefully Edith thought everything out – The picture is a good one, large and in good order, it is a watercolour (lady in gray dress) and is of Grandma Nicholls’ sister (our great aunt), born December 25th 1800. Mary Bradford Johns – she married Colonel Saunders, went to India with him (he was Indian army), he died, I believe out there: she returned to England, and against the wishes of her family, married our grandfather, Major Edward Sutherland, then a widower with a heap of daughters and one son, our father. She was much respected by all her step-children (no children by either husband) – she brought a lot of Indian rosewood furniture home, and the chair for you, was hers – you see, she was no blood relative of second family.

I have already quite plainly expressed my opinion of Frank – Edith gave me some years ago, a pair of Chelsea candlesticks and a miniature of our great aunt.

Among the papers that will go to Irene, is a certificate of our grandfather’s first marriage, to a widow: also the signature of Queen Victoria’s father, who was our grandfather’s godfather: they ought to have been left to you (they are useless to Frank, who cannot marry) nor is Irene likely to, but our poor cousin was obsessed with the idea of the “Beauchant” superiority in point of both (?) to our mother’s – now we need not refer to this again, and knowing how little you care about these matters, I need not do so, but keep this letter. Some day your children may want to know – I enclose p.o. for my flowers for Edie, please thank Ella for trouble taken – I am sure with good, kind, Miss Emmie, your home will be a ‘peace’ after this strain – Love from us both dear Edward,

Your affectionate sister

Nellie ```

Notes and reasoning

1 note, in the order written. Later notes may correct earlier ones; both are kept deliberately.

[0] Sister of Edward William Rose Jasper Sutherland; she signs herself “Your affectionate sister”. Living at 22 Waverley Road, Exmouth, Devon in Nov 1938, writing with a companion (“Love from us both”). Author of the 2 Nov 1938 letter that is the source for Major Edward Sutherland’s rank, his first marriage to a widow, the Duke of Kent godfather story, and the identification of the great-aunt Mary Bradford Johns. Placement as a full sister is PLAUSIBLE, not proven - she writes “your mother’s relatives” where a full sister might write “our”, though she does write “our mother’s” later.