Granny Mum family sign in

Home › Ancestry › People in the tree History

William John Edward Graham Sutherland

7 FEB 1839 – 20 Feb 1907

The account

Born 7 FEB 1839 at Ayrshire, Scotland. Occupation: Lieutenant Colonel, Army Pay Department; 44th Foot and 61st Foot. Child of Edward Sutherland and Catharine Beauchamp. Married Mary Nicholls, 13 Nov 1867, at St Columb Major. Children: Nellie Sutherland, Edward William Rose Jasper Sutherland (b. January 1871). Married Eliza Cregoe Beauchant, SEP 1878, at Truro, Cornwall, England. Children: Francis Graham Beauchant Sutherland (b. ABT 1880), Nowell Dunbar Ommanney Sutherland (b. 1 APR 1886), Irene Mary Primrose Sutherland (b. 19 APR 1887), Zoe Stephanie Catherine Sutherland (b. 20 NOV 1888), Thelence Sutherland (b. ABT 1892). Died 20 Feb 1907 at West Ham, Essex.

Recorded events

  • Born 7 FEB 1839, Ayrshire, Scotland Previously recorded as the bare “abt 1839” carried by the Ancestry export, with no place and no source. Replaced by this fuller date and place rather than kept alongside it - two birth events for one person is a data error, not extra detail. The evidence grade is still low: see the source note.
  • Died 20 Feb 1907, West Ham, Essex
  • Lieutenant Colonel, Army Pay Department; 44th Foot and 61st Foot HIS CAREER, FROM THE WAR OFFICE ITSELF. The rank and regiment were recorded here on 26 Jul 2026 as UNKNOWN, with a note that his service record was paywalled and unread. The family archive contained the answer all along: a War Office letter of 22 Jan 1925 furnishing, from the War Office Papers in the Public Record Office, the particulars of the military service of “Lieutenant Colonel W.J.E.G. Sutherland, A.P.D., 44th Foot and 61st Foot” - Ensign 44th Foot 11.3.1859; Lieutenant 1.4.1863; Captain 25.9.1869; Paymaster, 61st Foot, 1.4.1878. Services abroad: CHINA 9.10.1860 to 11.10.1861 and EAST INDIES 12.10.1861 to 14.2.1866. The letter adds that the Memoranda Papers record “Lieutenant Sutherland 44th foot was noted for the Lieutenancy of a Company of Cadets, Royal Military College in January, 1868 on the recommendation of Colonel Hort, 44th foot. 10 years service in March, 1869. No field service”, and that his name does NOT appear on the China Medal Roll of the 44th Foot. A.P.D. is the Army Pay Department, which he entered as Paymaster in 1878 and in which he reached Lieutenant Colonel; a separate Ancestry index entry gives him as Staff Paymaster in Oct 1902.
  • Army officer He appears in “UK, Officer Service Records, 1764-1932” and “UK, British Army Records and Lists” on Ancestry, consulted 26 Jul 2026. Both are paywalled and the records themselves have NOT been read, so the rank and regiment are unknown. An officer’s service record would give his birth date and place and often his next of kin.

Sources cited

  • Ancestry Family Trees
    • Ancestry Family Tree
  • Ancestry member trees and member-uploaded records
  • Various Ancestry users
    • Several Ancestry member trees and member-uploaded records, consulted 26 Jul 2026
  • War Office letter, 22 January 1925 - military record of Lt-Col W.J.E.G. Sutherland
  • W. Sansom, for the Under-Secretary of State, The War Office

What the evidence says

wjeg-commissions — corroborated

W.J.E.G. Sutherland was commissioned Ensign in the 44th Foot on 11 March 1859, Lieutenant 1 April 1863, Captain 25 September 1869, and Paymaster in the 61st Foot on 1 April 1878, retiring as a Lieutenant Colonel of the Army Pay Department.

“Ensign. 44th Foot. 11.3.1859. Lieutenant. 1.4.1863. Captain. 25.9.1869. Paymaster. 61st Foot. 1.4.1878.”

Source: War Office letter, 22 January 1925 - military record of Lt-Col W.J.E.G. Sutherland

Reasoning. Furnished by the War Office itself from its own papers, at the request of a Lieutenant-General, and precisely dated to the day. An Ancestry index entry independently gives him as Staff Paymaster in Oct 1902, consistent with a Pay Department career. This replaces a note reading ‘the rank and regiment are unknown’.

Next. Order WO 76 (officers’ services) and WO 25 for the Army Pay Department at Kew. Those are the files this letter was abstracted FROM, and an officer’s own papers give birth date and place and often name a father - which makes them a route to Major Edward Sutherland as well as a test of the Ayrshire 1839 birth.

wjeg-second-marriage — corroborated

W.J.E.G. Sutherland married a second time, in September 1878 at Truro, to Eliza Cregoe Beauchant, and had at least five further children by her.

“Married in September, 1878, Truro, Cornwall, to William John Edward Graham Major Sutherland ca 1839-1907”

Source: Ancestry ‘shoebox’ printouts, saved and printed August 2023

Reasoning. THE KEYSTONE FACT OF THIS BATCH. It was entirely unknown to this tree. It is supported not by the profile summary alone but by four independent baptism entries at Heywood St James, Lancashire, in 1886, 1887 and 1888, each naming the father as William John Edward Graham Sutherland and the mother as Eliza Cregoe Sutherland, and by the 1901 and 1911 censuses which put Eliza with a William Sutherland and then widowed. His first wife Mary Nicholls died 5 May 1875, so he was free to remarry. It also matches, and explains, a WikiTree profile found on 27 Jul 2026 for an ‘Eliza Cregoe (Beauchant) Sutherland’ whose husband could not then be identified.

Next. Order the Sept quarter 1878 GRO marriage certificate, Truro district - it gives both fathers’ names and occupations, and so is a second route to Major Edward Sutherland.

wjeg-service-abroad — corroborated

He served in China from 9 October 1860 to 11 October 1861 and in the East Indies from 12 October 1861 to 14 February 1866, but saw no field service and is not on the China Medal Roll of the 44th Foot.

“Services abroad:- China 9.10.1860 - 11.10.1861. East Indies 12.10.1861 - 14.2.1866.”

Source: War Office letter, 22 January 1925 - military record of Lt-Col W.J.E.G. Sutherland

Reasoning. Same official source. The letter is unusually careful to record the ABSENCE of evidence as well as its presence - no war service found, not on the medal roll - which is a mark of a conscientious abstract rather than a flattering one. His China dates fall in the closing phase of the Second Opium War.

Next. The 44th Foot’s movements 1860-66 are documented in regimental histories; they would place him month by month, and place his father’s household too if it travelled.

wjeg-birth-consistency — plausible

The 1859 ensigncy is consistent with, and mildly supports, the tree-sourced birth date of 7 February 1839.

“Ensign. 44th Foot. 11.3.1859.”

Source: War Office letter, 22 January 1925 - military record of Lt-Col W.J.E.G. Sutherland

Reasoning. Ensigns were commissioned typically between 16 and 20. A birth of 7 Feb 1839 makes him 20 years and one month at commission - within range and unremarkable. This does not prove the date, but it is the first HARD document that bears on it at all; until now the Ayrshire 1839 birth rested entirely on Ancestry member trees, a class of evidence that has already proved unreliable elsewhere in this tree.

Next. Only an Ayrshire OPR baptism of Feb 1839 or the WO 76 record will settle it.

Documents

  • named in Hand-drawn family tree — “rough copy of the … family — Mother’s [side]” (Johns / Sutherland / Wynne) — married Mary Johns

Notes and reasoning

2 notes, in the order written. Later notes may correct earlier ones; both are kept deliberately.

[0] Birth given as 7 FEB 1839 in AYRSHIRE, SCOTLAND by several Ancestry member trees and member- uploaded records, consulted 26 Jul 2026. TREE-SOURCED, NOT A RECORD - the same class of evidence that proved unreliable elsewhere in this tree, so it is recorded but not relied on. If it holds it is significant: it would place his father Major Edward Sutherland on garrison duty in SCOTLAND in 1839, and an Ayrshire OPR baptism of Feb 1839 would name both parents and so confirm the mother’s identity. He also appears in “UK, Officer Service Records, 1764-1932” and “UK, British Army Records and Lists” - he was an army officer like his father, and an officer’s service record would give his birth date and place and often his next of kin. Both are paywalled.

[1] THE 1859 ENSIGNCY TESTS THE 1839 BIRTH. An Ensign was commissioned typically between 16 and 20; a birth of 7 Feb 1839 makes him 20 years and one month at his commission on 11 Mar 1859. The tree-sourced Ayrshire birth date, flagged here as unreliable, is therefore consistent with the one hard military date we now hold. WHAT TO ORDER NEXT: the War Office letter is a 1925 ABSTRACT of files now at Kew. The underlying series are WO 76 (officers’ services) and, for the Pay Department, WO 25. Those would give his birth date and place in his own regiment’s hand and so test Ayrshire directly - and, because an officer’s papers often name a father, they are also a route to Major Edward Sutherland.